GAO Urges More Efforts to Combat Troops’ Fatigue

GAO Urges More Efforts to Combat Troops’ Fatigue

Soldiers sleeping
Photo by: U.S. Army/Lt. Col. John Hall

Service members are not getting enough sleep and are reporting poor sleep quality, according to a report from the Government Accountability Office.

“DoD and the services have administered and reported the results of surveys on service member fatigue for over a decade, consistently finding that service members report not getting the DoD recommended 7 or more hours of sleep each day or report getting poor quality of sleep,” the report says.

During the past five years, just over one-third of active-duty soldiers surveyed in the most recent Army Health of the Force report said they got seven or more hours of sleep a night, and the majority reported six hours of sleep or less, according to data cited in the GAO report.

For this most recent report, the GAO surveyed and incorporated responses from 190 officers serving in military occupations that are highly likely to experience fatigue.

The Army has taken several steps to address fatigue, including adding a section on sleep readiness in its Holistic Health and Fitness field manual published in October 2020, also known as FM 7-22, and issuing guidance for soldiers with specific jobs, such as air traffic controllers and vehicle operators.

Sleeping less than seven hours a night can have “significant effects on cognitive, emotional and physical capabilities that directly affect military performance,” including “deficits in marksmanship, physical training, decision-making and risk behavior,” according to a DoD survey from March 2021 cited in the report.

Fatigue or lack of sleep caused 8% of the Army’s tactical vehicle accidents between 2010 and 2019, according to a July 2021 GAO report cited in this recent report.

Even when Army jobs have sleep requirements, they do not always translate into adequate sleep for soldiers. “The constant change in my shift work schedule makes it difficult to get adequate sleep, this is in spite of my unit having good sleep policies in theory,” an Army helicopter pilot said in response to the GAO’s survey.

Looking to the future, wearable devices can proactively address sleep and related health issues. One example cited in the GAO report was the Optimizing the Human Weapon System program, which analyzes biometric data from wearable devices, such as sleep patterns and heart rate variability, to flag service members who may need supporting services or wellness checks.

“The program has demonstrated an ability to preemptively detect personnel hazards,” according to the report. “In one instance … program analysts detected an irregular sleep pattern from the wearable device worn by a soldier deployed to Afghanistan. This analysis prompted a wellness check by health officials embedded in the unit, and the soldier was found to be having suicidal thoughts, allowing Army health personnel to connect the service member with lifesaving resources.”

However, the GAO report also says that these programs may be too expensive to be implemented across the force.

Among other recommendations, the report indicates that the service secretaries, including the secretary of the Army, should delegate responsibility for promoting adequate sleep among service members to leadership in accordance with DoD Instruction 1010.10, which includes steps to mitigate troops’ sleep deprivation and promotes healthy sleep strategies.

“Fatigue and sleep deprivation among active-duty service members continues to be more the rule than the exception,” the report found. “Minimizing sleep deprivation and reducing fatigue for service members is a significant undertaking that will involve structural and cultural changes across the department.”

Read the GAO report here.